I'm really far behind on this....

1 hour ago, Tirion said:

I'm really far behind on this....

And 1 hour later....

#vote @GiledPallaeon

Sorry buddy but we haven't heard from you at all...Rebel scum laying low?

2 minutes ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

#vote @GiledPallaeon

Sorry buddy but we haven't heard from you at all...Rebel scum laying low?

So now its the quiet ones who are rebel scum and not me and Ard?

2 minutes ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

#vote @GiledPallaeon

Sorry buddy but we haven't heard from you at all...Rebel scum laying low?

That's true.

Too busy discussing the next victim.

Just now, Ginkapo said:

So now its the quiet ones who are rebel scum and not me and Ard?

Nah I still think you and Ard are very suspicious. But we have to kill somebody, and I think it might be easier to get a vote consensus on the non active player

I think he would be more active if he was a rebel.

#vote @CaribbeanNinja

4 minutes ago, Tirion said:

I think he would be more active if he was a rebel.

#vote @CaribbeanNinja

Well here is the thing...

As soon as we started, Mad voted right away and Ard got into it, but now they are really quiet. I'm guessing that is because we don't have a consensus, so they are as happy as clams right now.

I do think we have to take a chance and kill somebody. I'll take one for the team if need be.

13 minutes ago, Tirion said:

I think he would be more active if he was a rebel.

#vote @CaribbeanNinja

Is that your thoughts on thw whole game? Just this?

6 minutes ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

Well here is the thing...

As soon as we started, Mad voted right away and Ard got into it, but now they are really quiet. I'm guessing that is because we don't have a consensus, so they are as happy as clams right now.

I do think we have to take a chance and kill somebody. I'll take one for the team if need be.

I'm quiet because I'm hungrily devouring news of our Grorious Reader's newest naval triumph that will usher in a new era of safety and prosperity to the galaxy.

Also I'm playing Runewars tonight, so... gonna be quiet some more.

Celebrating mothers day for my mom tonight, but i am perfectly content with where my vote lies until more people start chiming in

1 hour ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

#vote @GiledPallaeon

Sorry buddy but we haven't heard from you at all...Rebel scum laying low?

It's called a life (read I am the one with car between me and SO). And on principle of thing I will now have to consider you, for grabbing me out of the blue. On reflection Gink or Ard are probably most suspicious in theory but neither is terribly OOC. So, on that note,

##vote @CaribbeanNinja

3 hours ago, Tirion said:

I think he would be more active if he was a rebel.

#vote @CaribbeanNinja

If this is your logic why Ninja? There are several that have been more active that you aren't considering.

##vote @Tirion

I legit have no idea atm. My general early round strategy in social deduction games is to try and catch a tell but no body language to read. The only person I feel good about is Gink because in the movies every imp is British.

58 minutes ago, DabDarklighter said:

If this is your logic why Ninja? There are several that have been more active that you aren't considering.

##vote @Tirion

Okay trying to get a consensus guys so we can make sure we do actually kill someone. I change my vote.

##vote @Tirion

1 hour ago, DabDarklighter said:

If this is your logic why Ninja? There are several that have been more active that you aren't considering.

##vote @Tirion

If I'm being honest I don't even know what I ninjad....... But go me!

If just talking makes you suspect, this is gonna get really boring really quick...

I'm not sold on anyone, but I do think 1) advocating for no lynching this early is mildly suspicious, and 2) I haven't really seen any significant flags from anyone else, so I'm staying on the crooked cook for now for lack of a better candidate.

On the other hand, Dab makes a solid point about the flaw in @Tirion 's logic, sooo... Definitely open to switching my vote if he can't come up with a better defense than "huh?"

1 hour ago, Madaghmire said:

I legit have no idea atm. My general early round strategy in social deduction games is to try and catch a tell but no body language to read. The only person I feel good about is Gink because in the movies every imp is British.

Right there with you. I'm pretty sure Gink is going all the way regardless of anything he does. Hope he's a loyalist and not just really good with accents!

3 hours ago, Ardaedhel said:

If just talking makes you suspect, this is gonna get really boring really quick...

I'm not sold on anyone, but I do think 1) advocating for no lynching this early is mildly suspicious, and 2) I haven't really seen any significant flags from anyone else, so I'm staying on the crooked cook for now for lack of a better candidate.

On the other hand, Dab makes a solid point about the flaw in @Tirion 's logic, sooo... Definitely open to switching my vote if he can't come up with a better defense than "huh?"

Hahaha I am not the first one that talk about no lynching. I just considered what was said cause no lynching never come up me before.

Hmm who was the first? I need some thread research...

ok. I am awake again, and apparently not much happened whilst I was asleep. 16 hours till deadline

Some notes:

1. Brobafett - Placed his vote on Ard for asking about roles, and since then has gone quiet. Blaming Mothers day for his inactivaty whilst saying that he isnt bothered and happy to let the clock run down.
2. Madaghmire - Making up excuses because of being new to this style. Day 1 is hard, no reason not to try.
3. Tirion - Done sweet piss all except vote CNinja for being quiet. About as hypocritical as you can get. Massive alarm bells going off here.
4. Ardeadhel - Did role fish, has since stopped that. Willing to engage with the game which is a rare thing here it seems. My gut says he was nieve rather than scum.
5. NobodyInParticular - Engaging, but appears to be more to show his name in thread than advance the game. I dont trust him, seems to have a good understanding of the game, but isnt applying that in any positive way for the imps.
6. ovinomanc3r - Seems lost. Likely indicative of an imperial trooper with no role and no information so playing completely blind at the moment.
7. DabDarklighter - Acknowledged that he is happy to take a back seat. Though has come on and voted for the strongest case since. Would like to see him come through on his word and actually push the case with others though. Its a little half hearted at the moment.
8. Ginkapo
9. Gilad Pallaeon - I dont care about your life outside this forum. You signed up. We have 16 hours left till lynch. Contribute.
10. Caribbean Ninja - All over the place with his logic, doesnt seem to be pushing cases hard so could potentially be similar to Ovino in that he is lost and blind.
11. Onidsen - Has clearly played a fair bit. We wont be able to read anything of his alignment on D1.

So to summarise.

Tirion is the strongest case right now as his vote is outright hypocritical. His vote on CNinj came at a time when the entire game appeared to be waiting for him to post. Thats a lot of pressure and he may have looked for a way to relieve pressure. It really didnt work as it had no substance at all.

Aside, I am suspicious of Mad and Nobody as well at the moment.

Unvote

Tirion currently sits at 4 votes, or lynch - 2 (L-2) as it is also known. So I wont vote yet as it makes it too easy for someone to hammer. First its time to squeeze all information out of him.

@Tirion - You are about to be lynched. Time to claim your role and argue for your skin. Why should we save you.

1 hour ago, Ginkapo said:

ok. I am awake again, and apparently not much happened whilst I was asleep. 16 hours till deadline

Some notes:

1. Brobafett - Placed his vote on Ard for asking about roles, and since then has gone quiet. Blaming Mothers day for his inactivaty whilst saying that he isnt bothered and happy to let the clock run down.
2. Madaghmire - Making up excuses because of being new to this style. Day 1 is hard, no reason not to try.
3. Tirion - Done sweet piss all except vote CNinja for being quiet. About as hypocritical as you can get. Massive alarm bells going off here.
4. Ardeadhel - Did role fish, has since stopped that. Willing to engage with the game which is a rare thing here it seems. My gut says he was nieve rather than scum.
5. NobodyInParticular - Engaging, but appears to be more to show his name in thread than advance the game. I dont trust him, seems to have a good understanding of the game, but isnt applying that in any positive way for the imps.
6. ovinomanc3r - Seems lost. Likely indicative of an imperial trooper with no role and no information so playing completely blind at the moment.
7. DabDarklighter - Acknowledged that he is happy to take a back seat. Though has come on and voted for the strongest case since. Would like to see him come through on his word and actually push the case with others though. Its a little half hearted at the moment.
8. Ginkapo
9. Gilad Pallaeon - I dont care about your life outside this forum. You signed up. We have 16 hours left till lynch. Contribute.
10. Caribbean Ninja - All over the place with his logic, doesnt seem to be pushing cases hard so could potentially be similar to Ovino in that he is lost and blind.
11. Onidsen - Has clearly played a fair bit. We wont be able to read anything of his alignment on D1.

So to summarise.

Tirion is the strongest case right now as his vote is outright hypocritical. His vote on CNinj came at a time when the entire game appeared to be waiting for him to post. Thats a lot of pressure and he may have looked for a way to relieve pressure. It really didnt work as it had no substance at all.

Aside, I am suspicious of Mad and Nobody as well at the moment.

Unvote

Tirion currently sits at 4 votes, or lynch - 2 (L-2) as it is also known. So I wont vote yet as it makes it too easy for someone to hammer. First its time to squeeze all information out of him.

@Tirion - You are about to be lynched. Time to claim your role and argue for your skin. Why should we save you.

As I said, I was watching and waiting. I think that waiting is done. You and several others have made good cases, and Tirion is most certainly the one with the strongest case. On that note,

##vote Tirion.

Sorry @Tirion but you really must explain yourself.

Someone unvote or the eager beavers (aka scum Nobody and Mad) can early hammer their teammate. Its so certain now that you get no credibility for these actions.w

4 minutes ago, Ginkapo said:

Someone unvote or the eager beavers (aka scum Nobody and Mad) can early hammer their teammate. Its so certain now that you get no credibility for these actions.w

And yet, had we been true scum, would we not have voted for somebody else with high votes to take pressure off of our teammate? I think you are looking too far into this Ginkapo. Perhaps I gain no credibility, perhaps I do, either way voting last doesn't mean I'm rebel. What if I had voted first and convinced other people to vote my way? Would you have suspected me of trying hard to convince others to kill a loyal Imperial? I waited until Tirion had a chance to excuse himself. The fact that everybody else voted either before he responded or while I was asleep (IRL) does not point to anything more malicious then delaying so as to hear the accused's side.

2 minutes ago, NobodyInParticular said:

And yet, had we been true scum, would we not have voted for somebody else with high votes to take pressure off of our teammate? I think you are looking too far into this Ginkapo. Perhaps I gain no credibility, perhaps I do, either way voting last doesn't mean I'm rebel. What if I had voted first and convinced other people to vote my way? Would you have suspected me of trying hard to convince others to kill a loyal Imperial? I waited until Tirion had a chance to excuse himself. The fact that everybody else voted either before he responded or while I was asleep (IRL) does not point to anything more malicious then delaying so as to hear the accused's side.

You have put him to L-1 before he has a chance to defend himself with 14 hours to go in the day?

Who could you have diverted the lynch onto at this point?