Salvatore was the first misstep into the abyss. KJA was bad enough but they doubled down on the hacks with RAS.

then creating a sci fi villian race for a space fantasy series in which the heroes have become super heroes with the powers of gods.

So so what's the logical next step? Kill the Wookiee. They one guy who could offer very unique perspectives in these books due to being the 'mute' alien character that can still be down to earth when the story called for it. Face it, none of the back writers could write for chewie and just wanted him dead because it was easier than one of the big three.

the final nail was the insane length of the series of novels in the NJO, what was as it; 20?

On 5/4/2017 at 0:33 PM, Jeff Wilder said:

... I'd managed to choke down Salvatore's Drizzt books (barely), ...

21 minutes ago, GrimmyV said:

... Salvatore was the first misstep into the abyss. KJA was bad enough but they doubled down on the backs with RAS...

Head hanging low, sheepishly dragging toe across the floor, I mumble "I like Drizzt. A lot."

1 hour ago, Bullox said:

Head hanging low, sheepishly dragging toe across the floor, I mumble "I like Drizzt. A lot."

It's ok, drizzt is a good character. He just happens to be the best thing made by a normally very bad writer.

I enjoyed the NJO. But, there are not nearly enough Vong ships to justify another faction.

12 hours ago, That Blasted Samophlange said:

Actually, the fate of JarJar was revealed. He eventually became a complete pariah to both gungan and naboo - friendless, pennyless, busking as a buffoon.

Not Enough.

HE MUST DIE!

48 minutes ago, Marinealver said:

Not Enough.

HE MUST DIE!

Why?

8 hours ago, Bullox said:

Head hanging low, sheepishly dragging toe across the floor, I mumble "I like Drizzt. A lot."

So does many more... He became one of the most known (and loved) character of the FR lore. People can dislike RA all they want, they cant sweep away the fact hes a very prolific and popular author who sold tons of books. Some of his characters and work still influence RPG to this day...

As for the Vong, well i guess i should accept that my personal taste are not shared

4 hours ago, Marinealver said:

Not Enough.

HE MUST DIE!

4 hours ago, Captain Lackwit said:

Why?

You are seriously asking why (should we kill Jar Jar Binks)?

Some people like the Vong, (hence why this thread is here) But no one likes Jar Jar Binks!

4 hours ago, Marinealver said:

You are seriously asking why (should we kill Jar Jar Binks)?

Some people like the Vong, (hence why this thread is here) But no one likes Jar Jar Binks!

But he stepped in poodoo, that's funny, right? And he lead the vote to give Palpatine emergency powers, that's hilarious!

I actually liked Jar Jar when I first watched the movie. Granted I was 6-7 years old, but I still don´t dislike him nowadays. THe Ewoks on the other hand, those I liked as a Kid, but grew up to hate them like nearly nothing else in Star Wars, weirdly enough.

On 5/4/2017 at 11:51 AM, Thormind said:

Anyone else would like to see the Yuuzhan Vong on screen and/or as a 4th faction in Xwing?

4 hours ago, Marinealver said:

You are seriously asking why (should we kill Jar Jar Binks)?

Some people like the Vong, (hence why this thread is here) But no one likes Jar Jar Binks!

I liked his cameo in Empires End, that was the apropriate way to handle that character. That book had Lumpy, too...

4 hours ago, Vode said:

THe Ewoks on the other hand, those I liked as a Kid, but grew up to hate them like nearly nothing else in Star Wars, weirdly enough.

I soooo much agree with you. Only difference is i hated them from the start. They are the reason why i dont like ROJ as much as the first two movies. I mean common, you throw a f'ing small stone at a guy in armor and you knock him out?? Hey, lets put talking teddy bears in one of the most loved space saga. It's gonna be great...

10 hours ago, Marinealver said:

You are seriously asking why (should we kill Jar Jar Binks)?

Some people like the Vong, (hence why this thread is here) But no one likes Jar Jar Binks!

Then why do you want him to have more screen time?

18 minutes ago, Thormind said:

I soooo much agree with you. Only difference is i hated them from the start. They are the reason why i dont like ROJ as much as the first two movies. I mean common, you throw a f'ing small stone at a guy in armor and you knock him out?? Hey, lets put talking teddy bears in one of the most loved space saga. It's gonna be great...

Yep that´s the very reason. Small teddy bears vs elite soldiers. And the teddys win...

No. Thank you anyway. Good day to you Sir.

I said good day! Be gone.

On 5/5/2017 at 0:04 PM, GrimmyV said:

Salvatore was the first misstep into the abyss. KJA was bad enough but they doubled down on the hacks with RAS.

then creating a sci fi villian race for a space fantasy series in which the heroes have become super heroes with the powers of gods.

So so what's the logical next step? Kill the Wookiee. They one guy who could offer very unique perspectives in these books due to being the 'mute' alien character that can still be down to earth when the story called for it. Face it, none of the back writers could write for chewie and just wanted him dead because it was easier than one of the big three.

the final nail was the insane length of the series of novels in the NJO, what was as it; 20?

None of the writers wanted to kill Chewie. They all loved him. It was mandated by the higher ups.

11 hours ago, GrimmyV said:

But he stepped in poodoo, that's funny, right? And he lead the vote to give Palpatine emergency powers, that's hilarious!

See, no redeeming qualities.

10 hours ago, Admiral Deathrain said:

I liked his cameo in Empires End, that was the apropriate way to handle that character. That book had Lumpy, too...

Need to kill him.

5 hours ago, TopHatGorilla said:

Then why do you want him to have more screen time?

So he can never have screen time again. As of now it is still possible for him to make a cameo. He was all in the clone wars videos. At least they didn't put him in Rebels but correct me if I'm wrong (just more reason we need to kill him).

2 minutes ago, Marinealver said:

See, no redeeming qualities.

Need to kill him.

So he can never have screen time again. As of now it is still possible for him to make a cameo. He was all in the clone wars videos. At least they didn't put him in Rebels but correct me if I'm wrong (just more reason we need to kill him).

Given that they're making movies and shows from multiple eras, killing him off doesn't guarantee he can't see more screen time

8 minutes ago, VanderLegion said:

Given that they're making movies and shows from multiple eras, killing him off doesn't guarantee he can't see more screen time

3 hours ago, Marinealver said:

Ani, what happened to yousa?

1 minute ago, GrimmyV said:

Ani, what happened to yousa?

22 hours ago, Marinealver said:

You are seriously asking why (should we kill Jar Jar Binks)?

Some people like the Vong, (hence why this thread is here) But no one likes Jar Jar Binks!

Yeah I'm asking why. I never really minded him that much.

Isa Darth Jar Jar gonna have to choka Sith?!

Another NOOOOO to the Vong being in X-Wing. I had stopped reading Star Wars books shortly before the NJO started, due to the amount of crap there, and hearing about the Vong solidified my decision. To echo what other people have said, they are a bad enemy, simply taking all the strengths of the heroes and going 'Nope!'.
Going back into the Clone Wars would be much better for X-wing, for many reasons: Ships have appeared in film, so are recognisable; ships are somewhat similar to existing ships, meaning you aren't introducing a whole new set of mechanics; Some clone wars ships can fit into existing factions.