I've read too much and managed to confuse myself again, so it's time to ask third partirs again.

A ship with APT attacks a other ship with one shield left. Rolls two hit/crits.

The question is, how many faceup cards the target gonna get. One because there is a crit or two because the APT gives an extra faceup card?

Only one faceup, the APT effect. This happens first and is in addition to the 4 damage rolled. Then, you resolve the other 4 damage without a critical effect. In your scenario, a shield and 3 hull (face down). So, your target gets a face up card (APT), looses a shield, and 3 more face down. It's important to resolve the crit before all other damage as it may take shields away before the other damage is resolved.

23 minutes ago, Norell said:

I've read too much and managed to confuse myself again, so it's time to ask third partirs again.

A ship with APT attacks a other ship with one shield left. Rolls two hit/crits.

The question is, how many faceup cards the target gonna get. One because there is a crit or two because the APT gives an extra faceup card?

You can only trigger 1 crit (unless Fire-Control team).

So you could do 1 faceup by APT.

Or 1 faceup by default (if you get through to hull).

But not both.

How many crit icons you roll is irrelevant. You only need 1.

Yeah, that too^^^^

If I roll 5 crits, I don't think of it that way, I think of it as 5 damage with critical effect.

I was just confused about the crit effects. Thanks

Just to clarify your original scenario:

Hit/crit and hit/crit from an APT vs a hull zone with 1 shield remaining = 4 damage with a critical effect.

Evade (or Admonition) - let's assume none

Resolve critical effects: If you choose to use APT then you deal and resolve a face-up card now or the standard critical effect is just that the first damage card dealt is face up.

Spend and resolve other defence tokens - let's assume none

4 damage is dealt 1 to shields then 3 cards to the hull. If you hadn't chosen APT then the standard critical effect would mean that is 1 face up and 2 face down.

2 hours ago, Green Knight said:

You can only trigger 1 crit (unless Fire-Control team).

<...>

How many crit icons you roll is irrelevant. You only need 1.

This. It's worth explicitly pointing out that Fire Control Team would let you resolve the APT and the standard crit effect, for two face up cards, even if a single hit/crit had been rolled .

Oops, yeah I read that wrong. But resolving the crit is what's important. I'll edit it later when I'm not traveling to ensure it's accurate.