We resolved things differently in our case for the current epic seaons with the following rule:
- Each army must have a "general" and "Lieutenant"
- The General must be a huge ship with unique upgrade (title or character) or a large unique pilot.
- The lieutenant must be a large unique pilotor a small unique pilot.
- The combined points of general and lieutenant must be 80 points or higher
- The general must be worth more than the lieutenant.
That way, scum armies could still be played (or other "swarm" type armies), but they had to invest the equivalent of a huge ship into a few elites. So far, it worked out pretty well and we had some nice feedback.
How often have you guys tested this system? Anybody bring some of the power combos to the table in this format? How do the capital ships fare against these lists? I'm really curious, as I'm attempting to get an epic tournament running locally.