A group of us recently started a 3v3 CC campaign, which has taken a strange turn...
The second game of round one was a bit of a disaster for the defenders, resulting in a victory that will probably have repercussions for the rest of the campaign. While we were going over what went wrong, we noticed the attacker's list had been changed after the initial strategy phase. It can be argued that on paper the changes may not have made much of a difference, however looking at the way the battle unfolded, it gave the attacker the edge he needed against the defender's list/objectives.
Now this is the awkward part... the attacker did not submit a written list (i know what you are thinking, but we are supposed to be all adults here), however joking comments were made about a few squadron choices, so we had a pretty good idea about what he had. Also, the whole campaign was tracked in google spreadsheet form, which was open for all to observe. Looking at the lists post-battle, it was noticed that between the day before the game and the time of play, the list was modified (which was tracked in revision history). When asked about it, the player denied any changes, but with a few screenshots that was proven false. Then, the original spreadsheet was replaced with a new one (minus revision history)... when that was pointed out, the enter campaign data went missing (unfortunately, the player organizing the spreadsheet was the one we were having issues with). This was all accidental of course.
So after all this, one team is left with a bad taste in their mouth. Not really sure how to proceed, or even if we want to continue at this point. Every game is going to be suspect now, which really sucks the fun out of something we were all excited about. If any of you folks have any thoughts it would be appreciated.
