Okay, so I'm wondering about loot, just to start. There's a maybe short list of things that even a Rogue Trader would either find it very hard to acquire, despite having a planet's worth of money, and a sector's worth of connections, and a few things they just can't get. They can requisition a Baneblade, and the unit of Guardsman infantry attached to it. They can acquire some of the most powerful weapons such vessels can carry. In one instance, they can even claim a Titan, sort of. One of those categories of things out of their league is "Astartes Stuff". Even Calligos Winterscale, as far as I know the richest, most powerful NPC RT in Koronus, could not likely acquire a Land Raider, or a Thunderhawk, without just stealing it from the Space Marines, with all that plan entails, partly because they are rare, partly because they are in the hands of Space Marines, and he has no known ties to any Chapters, and mostly because, if I understand things right, the Emperor actually decreed that only Astartes could use the two above mentioned things; the Imperial Army once had Land Raiders (Guard had a powerful transport, at one time), and the Big E ordered all of them to be seconded to the Legiones Astartes, and only made for them.
So, I get that, even in their height of power, a Rogue Trader would find it difficult to obtain a Land Raider, or a Thunderhawk, but what about the Traitor models? I've played 40K, but I've never fielded Chaos before, and when I was playing, the Thunderhawk wasn't even a model (now, I think it's mostly a FW model, and mostly for Apocalypse games, but it DOES exist), though I know my friend had two Land Raiders for his Noise Marines. Certainly, any such vehicle, in the hands of the Chaos Space Marines for so long, will be tainted, but if they can pull a ship out of a corrupted Space Hulk, I'd think it would be possible to "purify" one of these, too. If your party happened to battle CSMs, which is mean, but certainly doable, and, after besting them, took their ride (pick one), if they got it cleaned up, what would happen to it? Most of the Traitor Legions don't have too much for Loyalist elements, and it would seem weird to take an Iron Warriors Land Raider, and hand it off to the Blood Angels. If we ignore that silly (not saying untrue; just convenient and silly) "lesser hands unworthy" element of Astartes gear (some of the machine spirits will be lost, with the warp taint), and a Rogue Trader happened to claim a Traitor Legion Thunderhawk, and put his amazing Explorator, and Missionary, to work, cleaning it up, would the Imperium step in, and just take it, or would the Rogue Trader, having the right to claim spoils, get a new, awesome ride, albeit maybe a little less awesome, as some bits might not make it through the exorcism? Yes, this is snowflakery, but the entire point, sometimes, of being a Rogue Trader, is to have the ambition, and arrogance, to claim what no one else can, and if they can be trusted with a ship it took a century to build, and can end continents, or worlds, what's a Thunderhawk, one of the most easily fabricated aircraft in the Imperium, if the Internet is to be believed? At a few points in the TT, Inquisitors could field a Land Raider as a Dedicated Transport, and that was written by Games Workshop (Thunderhawks just weren't a model, yet), so I'm wondering if, after footing the bill themselves, a Rogue Trader could have another "look what you'll never own " trophy, or if some element of the Imperium would say "no one can defy the Emperor, and He said only His sons could have these!", and take it, and then, not being Astartes, give it to some Chapter, however they'd pick? Just curious, and thought I'd ask, before the boards went poof.
if your party found one, how would you explain to them they can't have it, and what would you have them do with it, instead, or would you let them have it, on their own bill, as Peers of the Imperium? (A Rogue Trader CAN have equal authority to an Astartes Chapter Master.)
Edited by venkelos