That is how you grow a good community!For a game that's been out less than two weeks I see nothing wrong with that. They're obviously meant to be played out of the box, so go play them out of the box!
Considering all the usual 'Fly Casual' hooplah I see over on the X-Wing forums there sure are a lot of people taking this game too seriously. If a new player walked up to you with nothing but a starter would you seriously tell him/her to kick rocks because it's not a 'standard' deck?
Of course not... but I'd make sure they understood that they were probably going to lose. I play a mill deck and they're effectively starting with 1/3 of their deck "pre-milled". It's not going to be a positive experience for either of us.
Maybe it's just me, but if that occurred, I'd likely ask them to give me 5 minutes to either:
1. Reconstruct the opposite starter from my collection so we are on more event terms
-or-
2. let them borrow a character that compliments their starter and 10 more cards so they can get a better appreciation of the game.
Indeed. As opposed to, say, buying a box and whining about how you didn't pull any characters (which is understandably frustrating), but then for some strange reason refusing to trade or interact with the secondary market.
That's just it. We're Star Wars fans! We Fly Casual in X-wing and will bring that same level of friendship and fun to this game. Let the "serious gamers" have their MTG.
Now now, let's not be disingenuous. There's nothing wrong with Magic.
Edited by WonderWAAAGH