Honestly, I'm not mad about them. The relative scale/skew seems off on the Starkiller one, but the Hoth one just looks outright awful. I'd have been much happier with it if they'd just had the white of the planet with some terrain detail. It it no way gels with the horizon line, or even the perspective. Shame, too. They did a decent job on the previous offerings.
I use a 3rd party mat for X-wing. It's heavy vinyl, but the print quality is excellent, and it has a non-slip base. I'm very happy with it. That said, I wouldn't say no to one with that neoprene build. A few of the guys use them in the store, and they're great to play on. I'm just not mad about the price of the FFG ones, vs what I can get 3rd party.
