Of these 2 lists which one would everyone prefer using and or avoid playing against or with.Thanks ahead of time for your thoughts and input.

First one is this:

Omicron pilot with Mangler cannon + title + Palp.

Howlrunner + crackshot.

3 x black squad pilots + crackshot.

Or

2 x u boats + Extra munitions + plasma torps + overclocked r-4 + feedback array + deadeye + chips.

2 x black sun soldiers + feedback array.

I play almost exclusively rebels, and my lists can be a little unconventional, so advice best taken with a pinch of salt...

But that said, almost all of the lists I have prepped for near future use would have a much easier time against the crackswarm than the torpedo boats.