An interesting (an old) tournament format idea

By CJKeys, in X-Wing

I was thinking.... everyone is talking about ban lists and such. I propose a simpler solution, a new format: Highlander.

Highlander format every card in the game would be unique. Not much else to say, but it creates a sort of composition rule that makes it impossible to spam ships and impossible to spam upgrades.

Thoughts?

Unfortunately it also makes it impossible to run some really fun swarm/mini-swarm lists :(

Cheers

Baaa

Unfortunately it also makes it impossible to run some really fun swarm/mini-swarm lists :(

Cheers

I can feel you there, I think thought it could lead to some creative builds

Highlander format every card in the game would be unique. Not much else to say, but it creates a sort of composition rule that makes it impossible to spam ships and impossible to spam upgrades.

I don't know. This makes certain lists disappear completely from viability, but does absolutely nothing to tackle squads like Palp Shuttle + Whisper + Omega Leader. It just removes some of the tools other squads might have to deal with it. What problem are you trying to solve?

Highlander format every card in the game would be unique. Not much else to say, but it creates a sort of composition rule that makes it impossible to spam ships and impossible to spam upgrades.

I don't know. This makes certain lists disappear completely from viability, but does absolutely nothing to tackle squads like Palp Shuttle + Whisper + Omega Leader. It just removes some of the tools other squads might have to deal with it. What problem are you trying to solve?

It isnt to solve a particular problem, but instead creates a new format that would have it's own meta that would have to diverge from the current meta. I know it instantly kills thug life, bbbz, tie swarm, crack swarm, torpscouts. In that though it creates an environment that requires mixed pilot builds.

What about a unique/limited only tourny where you can only bring ships with unique pilots and upgrades that are limited or unique only. Not sure what to do about ordnance as that gets hosed unless all ordnance counted as unique. This removes all EPT and mod slots and a bunch of crew so it is also naked ships vs naked ships

Edited by Oberron

It's not the worst idea, but as has been stated, it does nothing to some lists while removing like, Crackswarms and U-Boats entirely. So...meh. There are probably better casual formats to explore.


TIE Swarm lives (in an odd way) Unnamed Squadron ( 100 )



Black Squadron Pilot — TIE Fighter 14 Crack Shot 1 Ship Total: 15

"Howlrunner" — TIE Fighter 18 Predator 3 Stealth Device 3 Ship Total: 24

Academy Pilot — TIE Fighter 12 Ship Total: 12

"Youngster" — TIE Fighter 15 Expose 4 Ship Total: 19

"Backstabber" — TIE Fighter 16 Ship Total: 16

"Wampa" — TIE Fighter 14 Ship Total: 14

Edited by CJKeys

Omicron Group Pilot (21)

Emperor Palpatine (8)


The Inquisitor (25)

Push the Limit (3)

Autothrusters (2)

TIE/v1 (1)


"Omega Leader" (21)

Juke (2)

Comm Relay (3)


"Wampa" (14)


Total: 100





Omega Leader + Wampa can be swapped out for a Vessery, Whisper, or Vader of your choice, too. In all cases, it's trivial to keep every upgrade card unique... and they're all perfectly flyable Palp Aces builds.


I somehow doubt this was quite what you had in mind when trying to 'diversify' the listbuilding. ;)