I have been out of X-Wing for a bit, and need a little advice for a local tournament. I will be flying 3 Tie Defenders. Which of the three list would be a best list, and how would you fly this list.

List 1:

36 = Ryad (34) + PTL (3) + TIE MK II (1) + Tie/x7 (-2)

35 = Glaive (34) + Juke (2) + TIE MK II (1) + Tie/x7 (-2)

29 = Delta (30) + TIE MK II (1) + Tie/x7 (-2)

List 2:

32 = Ryad (34) + Tie/x7 (-2)

33 = Maarek (35) + Tie/x7 (-2)

37 = Rexler (37) + Tie/x7 (-2)

List 3:

36 = Ryad (34) + PTL (3) + TIE MK II (1) + Tie/x7 (-2)

35 = Maarek (35 + VI (1) + TIE MK II (1) + Tie/x7 (-2)

29 = Delta (30) + TIE MK II (1) + Tie/x7 (-2)

Tactics:

1) Fly in a close swam

2) Fly in a lose swam

3) Fly with one flanker

4) Fly all independent of each other.

Thanks! :-)

This is the defender list I've used to great success in several local store tournies and leagues:

34 = Glaive (34) + Tie/x7 (-2) + Juke

34 = Glaive (34) + Tie/x7 (-2) + Juke

32 = Ryad (34) + Tie/x7 + Adaptability

They all run at PS6, there is not one that is a clear target because while the Glaives with Juke are nasty, Ryad can be insane too with her pilot ability so losing any one doesn't really matter.

I'm 37 and 2 with this list.

Please ignore, I reposted under a different title.

All look solid, however I'm a fan of list 1 - mainly because the Glaive with Juke is one of my fav defenders to fly. The combo of the title with Juke, three evades and the ability to take a focus is pretty strong.