I have found that it does.
I don't think anyone is doubting that is a bad build, but it's really a matter of keeping track of when MK actually helps you. You could probably drop MK from that and see almost no fall off in damage, depending on target of course, but as in the ISD example, it only lets you push 1 more damage through.
I found the Star Cruiser with XI7, Spinal and Mon Karren to be fantastic. It is more expensive than just XI7's and HTT's but I get Spinal where as to get the same level of red I would have to use a Battlecruiser
That's an neat idea to get around the contain tokens on the big ships. I'm a bit more partial to just doing more damage so I've been liking Spinal Armaments, XI7s, and Leading Shots on a Liberty because I like fishing for the red dice double hit.
I like the card,but I'm not sure it's worth 8 points. Take a Liberty with XI7s and a Liberty with MK, with the same damage roll against almost anything, an ISD for example, and the difference is 1 damage on another shield zone.
I disagree. Sure it could be done easier but Mon Karren offers you a strong advantage. It allows you push far more damage through.Yup MK really is not that great. There is only one build that really makes any sense for it. To be honest you can accomplish the same thing easier.
We shall see but I like it.
-edit - I do realize that sometimes it all comes down to 1 extra damage.
XI-7s with XX-9s might be able to push more damage through than Mon Karren, but then it becomes a slight gamble.
If you drop MK you do see a fall because now you only have XI7's to mitigate. They can still brace, redirect, and evade (Gladiator, Needa, etc) while HTT's and XI7's can still get hit all 3 and mitigate 4 damage and take the rest on the shields.
Mon Karren means that if you accuracy their brace they can only redirect or evade. They mitigate far less damage.
Even in your example, w/o MK, if you accuracy the brace, they can only mitigate 2, and that's only at long range (you like the starcruiser from your past statements, so probably you're firing at medium range). The issue isn't that MK doesn't help, it absolutely does, but if it's worth it. I think it can be but I honestly think the value of MK has been overstated.