thief ability in the village

By Tomazo, in Talisman Rules Questions

Does the thiefs ability to take an item for free allow him to take the item AND to do something in the village during the same turn?

also, can he go and take gold or items from other players INSTEAD of battling them? or is it rather a result after combat?

I am unable to locate anything in the rules that says otherwise, therefore I see no reason why the Thief cannot take a purchase item AND visit one of the village options in the same turn.

When a player lands on another player, they have the option to either use a special ability on the other player OR attack them. Therefore, yes, the Thief can land on another player and use their ability to take an item and not do battle with them.

Tomazo said:

Does the thiefs ability to take an item for free allow him to take the item AND to do something in the village during the same turn?

Hi Tomazo,

If you choose, to use the special ability with the Thief in the village, then you can't buy other objects, nor visiting the healer or mystic.

Greetings,

Velhart

>>>Hi Tomazo,

If you choose, to use the special ability with the Thief in the village, then you can't buy other objects, nor visiting the healer or mystic.

Greetings,

Velhart<<<


I dont want to be a bother, but can you direct me to the rules that backup that statement? As I stated in my reply, I am unable to locate anything in the rules that says that you cannot use a character's ability and follow instructions on a board space at the same time. The character card itself does not state that there is a limitation.

Gelmaron said:

>>>Hi Tomazo,

If you choose, to use the special ability with the Thief in the village, then you can't buy other objects, nor visiting the healer or mystic.

Greetings,

Velhart<<<


I dont want to be a bother, but can you direct me to the rules that backup that statement? As I stated in my reply, I am unable to locate anything in the rules that says that you cannot use a character's ability and follow instructions on a board space at the same time. The character card itself does not state that there is a limitation.

I heard it from Jon New long ago gui%C3%B1o.gif

But i have send the question to John Goodenough, and we have finally the official answer ! gran_risa.gif

Question: I have a question about the Thief. Can you steal and buy objects in the village at the same time?

A: Yes

Here we have it it gui%C3%B1o.gif

Velhart said:

But i have send the question to John Goodenough, and we have finally the official answer ! gran_risa.gif

Question: I have a question about the Thief. Can you steal and buy objects in the village at the same time?

A: Yes

Here we have it it gui%C3%B1o.gif

What about Healer + Steal and Mystic + Steal?

Velhart said:

Gelmaron said:

>>>Hi Tomazo,

If you choose, to use the special ability with the Thief in the village, then you can't buy other objects, nor visiting the healer or mystic.

Greetings,

Velhart<<<


I dont want to be a bother, but can you direct me to the rules that backup that statement? As I stated in my reply, I am unable to locate anything in the rules that says that you cannot use a character's ability and follow instructions on a board space at the same time. The character card itself does not state that there is a limitation.

I heard it from Jon New long ago gui%C3%B1o.gif

But i have send the question to John Goodenough, and we have finally the official answer ! gran_risa.gif

Question: I have a question about the Thief. Can you steal and buy objects in the village at the same time?

A: Yes

Here we have it it gui%C3%B1o.gif

Thanks for the info, Velhart happy.gif

Dam said:

Velhart said:

But i have send the question to John Goodenough, and we have finally the official answer ! gran_risa.gif

Question: I have a question about the Thief. Can you steal and buy objects in the village at the same time?

A: Yes

Here we have it it gui%C3%B1o.gif

What about Healer + Steal and Mystic + Steal?

Hi Dam,

I have send the question some weeks ago, and i receive a unexpected answer from John.

--------------

Question: Can you only use the steal ability from the thief when you visit the Blacksmith, Healer, or Mystic in the Village?

A: Yes

--------------------

It seems that you can always steal, no matter who you visit...

It's a bit weird for me, that's why i have wait to post this answer.. happy.gif

Now that i have post the answer above.... me and my opponent, have decided that we will not allow this rule to happen.

The meaning of the thief is to steal, where you can buy objects etc, such as market, market day and blacksmith.

It's very weird to me, that a thief can steal objects by the mystic, or healer. This makes no sense at all.

I have also ask John if he says the same about the merchant. I am still waiting for his response..