Decision time for the United Kingdom tomorrow.

By FTS Gecko, in X-Wing Off-Topic

Maybe votes with far-reaching consequences should be weighted based on the fraction of life expectancy remaining.

That's hugely undemocratic though, Should we also do that for medicare? They're old they aren't gonna be around long enough to really benefit, that money could be used elsewhere.

Maybe votes with far-reaching consequences should be weighted based on the fraction of life expectancy remaining.

Maybe they should always come with an "are you sure?" referendum a week or two later.

You can have some education without government obviously, but not mass education. Not universal.

Fair enough.

I think it is about the Brexit. It's the same sort of "we can take care of ourselves" blanket nonsense.

This I can agree with. (Again, libertarian anarchist.)

How did you type ≠?

I didn't even know that symbol existed - why do we always use != or <> in programming?

Maybe votes with far-reaching consequences should be weighted based on the fraction of life expectancy remaining.

That's hugely undemocratic though, Should we also do that for medicare? They're old they aren't gonna be around long enough to really benefit, that money could be used elsewhere.

You can have some education without government obviously, but not mass education. Not universal.

Fair enough.

I think it is about the Brexit. It's the same sort of "we can take care of ourselves" blanket nonsense.

This I can agree with. (Again, libertarian ≠ anarchist.)

Maybe votes with far-reaching consequences should be weighted based on the fraction of life expectancy remaining.

That's hugely undemocratic though, Should we also do that for medicare? They're old they aren't gonna be around long enough to really benefit, that money could be used elsewhere.
I was joking, obviously.

You joke but I'll bet there isn't a single politician who wouldn't love this scenario. Give the 18-25 year old with a chip on their shoulder against boomers more say than anyone else.

The political system in Canada is not much better than the States. We have two big parties (Liberals & Conservatives), 1 medium (NDP), and a smattering of small parties (Green, Bloc). The majority of them are leftist for the most pat. Part of the liberals campaign was to change the voting system so that people would select their first, second and third choice. This sounds pretty good until you take into account that Liberals are almost always going to be second choice when they aren't first. I vote NDP, then I'm going to select Liberal as my second choice because they aren't the Conservatives. I vote Conservative, I'm going to select Liberal as my second choice because they aren't the NDP.

If this system get's put into place then Liberals will almost certainly never lose power in Canada. Will they do it? Who knows but they have a majority so they definitely can if they want.

Maybe votes with far-reaching consequences should be weighted based on the fraction of life expectancy remaining.

That's hugely undemocratic though, Should we also do that for medicare? They're old they aren't gonna be around long enough to really benefit, that money could be used elsewhere.

Don't they, at least in America? In an episode of House they were choosing who to give an organ to and his age counted against one bloke.

Do I see people complain about politics?

I am afraid I need the help of a separate thread and at least another local (are you with me, mr. Graves? ;) ) to explain the Belgian system :P

The crude summary is it is a smaller version of Europe.

I am really interested what happens next in the UK and am rather worried for friends whose resources weren't great to begin with..

Also if, IF, the UK opts out and Scotland leaves the UK but remains in the EU, this would be a large incentive for other regions to reach for independence.

Maybe even create a precedent for others to use.....

Edited by Cununculus

...already plenty of Londoners talking about the City of London becoming a Singapore-style city state.

And liverpool, that wants to be seperate and still part of the EU.

I hate liverpool but i'd live there in a shot if that was the option for staying :)

I've ranted a lot about this these last few days.

I'mma just copy what I put on my facebook:

Well, a friend of mine said i'm better than just copy pasting other peoples opinions and as much as I don't always agree I gotta admit he has a point.

I'm going to write up my own thoughts on brexit. Feel free to skip this, delete me as a friend, call me unpatriotic, call me a bit of a ****. Whatever.

I think it's a bad idea.

I think that if Donald Trump thinks it's a good idea, then it's REALLY a bad idea.

But let me expand, see this is 2016. We've had 2-3 successive full decades of absolute mega-globalization. Immigration is everywhere, look at me an Englishman settled down and living comfortably in canada. Sure the ripples brexit will cause will hit me, but i'm far enough away from the blast zone to remain unaffected. I have family, relatives in France. I am more than a little more concerned for them

My single biggest concern with the UK exiting the EU is that I believe we are heading towards a point in global politics where the larger federations and nations hold the advantage. We have an increasingly xenophobic US, an increasingly economically aggressive China, and an increasingly just plain aggressive Russia.

Faced with this, I strongly believe that Europe does need to band together, and that together we are stronger.

The single biggest reasoning for leaving the EU that I have heard has been immigration, and "taking our country back". Now i've seen all the posts about this new wave of racism and it disgusts me, I mean actually makes me ashamed to be British. I come from a country that was a shining beacon of tolerance, free speech and has a famous history of defending others (at least last century) All those Polish guys who you want to go home? Well first off their grandparents probably settled here after helping fight the battle of Britain. Otherwise... well didn't we go to war with Germany over them being invaded? That's gotta count for something.

Also we've colonized half the **** world, we are gonna be bringing some people back now and again, just saying.

I can't speak to the economic benefits of leaving the EU vs staying, but I can't imagine leaving would be better. The EU won't want anyone else to leave fearing a collapse, so they will literally have to twist the knife as much as possible. That's a real concern. The UK hasn't stood alone in 20+ years, picking up and going self sufficient from where we left off just won't happen.

I've heard rumours that article 50, the paper that gets the UK out won't even be actioned, and that politicians will either veto it or whatever. That's the best case situation. I am reading this that the best case situation is the UK government actually admitting that the general public's opinions don't matter. That's a black day in itself.

I've not put hours of research into this, I'm a husband, I'm a father. I have no time. But I do give a ****, and guys... I can't see how leaving the EU will be a positive thing in either the short or long term.

Thank you for reading. Do with this as you will.

And liverpool, that wants to be seperate and still part of the EU.

I hate liverpool but i'd live there in a shot if that was the option for staying :)

Liverpool's fine its the scousers who live there that's the problem.

The thing is if they ignored the referendum result immediately there would be an outcry

But... every single second someone realises what a colossal mistake they have made as promises get overturned, the pound depreciates, banks stop trading, a market closes, someone in their street has their window broken for the crime of being italian

etc etc.

The mood is changing among a lot of people.

The big one though is realising that leaving the EU makes it harder to control borders and none of the money 'saved' will be spent on what it was supposed to be spent on, in fact rather than saving the NHS... UKIP now want to sell it off.

And liverpool, that wants to be seperate and still part of the EU.

I hate liverpool but i'd live there in a shot if that was the option for staying :)

Liverpool's fine its the scousers who live there that's the problem.

Well in fairness i cant fault them, as a region they voted to stay 'in'

Unlike wales, sunderland and cornwall... who voted out, then realised they are massively subsidised by the EU and are now pannicking about where that 250m quids worth of small business loans and grants is going to come from.

Does this mean Brits can't buy x-wing anymore?

Does this mean Brits can't buy x-wing anymore?

They never bought anything, they just fight over it whenever the ship shows up which is why it's called the Pound.

Does this mean Brits can't buy x-wing anymore?

They never bought anything, they just fight over it whenever the ship shows up which is why it's called the Pound.

Does this mean Brits can't buy x-wing anymore?

No but it means that if you're in the US and want to buy some stuff from Cog O' Two, now's the time.

If you don't already you should check out this podcast:

http://www.dancarlin.com/

makes me ashamed to be British

Couldn't agree more. I have never been quite so disappointed in my place of birth (not sure I can really call it 'home' anymore)

Does this mean Brits can't buy x-wing anymore?

It probably means they're going to get a lot more expensive as I'm assuming Esdevium has to buy them in dollars or euros.

And yeah, I've written a lot on this topic, but suffice it to say, I'm disgusted by how the two main campaigns ran, I think the amount of barefaced lies told basically entirely invalidates the result as it wasn't remotely an informed choice, and I'm absolutely bloody terrified about my future.

Edited by thespaceinvader

makes me ashamed to be British

Couldn't agree more. I have never been quite so disappointed in my place of birth (not sure I can really call it 'home' anymore)

Me neither.

The racism, hatred and division is not what England has stands for, not to me.

Never have I been so rankled.

The big problem is that the 'leave' campaign have 'won' but achieved none of their goals.

There is no exit strategy because they never thought they would win.

This post is very long but well worth reading. it's not by me, its by a lady far more erudite than I.

It is day four in the Big Brexit house.

I had hoped after Friday’s absolute catastrophe of a day that the country might somehow magically rally over the weekend. I mean, when you plunge your country into possible ruin on the promise of a golden future that will allow it to rise like a phoenix from the flames, you have a plan, right?

As it turns out, you don’t. The only person that seems to have any plan at all, and be acting on it rather than just spouting meaningless Churchillian rhetoric is Nicola Sturgeon, and I can’t even vote for her.

I was distraught and angry on Friday. I had hoped to feel better by today. Instead I am running on barely controlled rage and getting more enraged by the moment.

Here are a few things I am furious about:

Firstly, leave voters telling me to calm down. I’m sorry, many of you are my friends and family but you do not get to say this. I’m not angry at you individually. I’m angry at where we are and more, I’m incandescent at the way we got here. I have a right to be angry. I’m in the boat with you and I don’t like where we’re going. I have very little option with regard to getting out of the boat, and I’d feel happier if someone was actually steering it, but they’re not. I’m sorry if my anger makes you uncomfortable, but you have the choice to not to speak to me, or unfriend me if you feel better doing that. Please do, because I don’t think I’m going to get any less angry for quite some time.

Secondly, people telling me that this is democracy and I have to live with it. You know what? The referendum vote was simply one part of the democratic process, and as I keep mentioning to those who conveniently forget it, it was ‘Advisory,’ not legally binding. The vote itself is not ‘democracy’. Democracy doesn’t happen on one day for one vote and then go away again. Democracy is an ongoing process in which we are free to express ourselves however we see fit as long as we do not descend into hate speech (which I haven’t). Democracy is part of a process and is happening all the time. I have the democratic right to fight against decisions made on my behalf that I don’t like, and I don’t like this one, so I am fighting it every step of the way. Do not throw the word democracy in my face. It is not a trump card.

Thirdly, people telling me that what we have to do now is ‘pull together’ to ‘make this country great.’ Not one single person who has chastised me with the ‘pulling together’ line has actually answered me when I’ve asked how they’re going to do that. Unless you’re a millionaire or a business owner, or a politician, there are very few ways you can ‘pull together’ unless you’re going to get politically active. Like the term ‘democracy,’ it is being used in a way that is actually meaningless. Mostly, as far as I can see it is being used as short hand for ‘Don’t blame me. Don’t ask me. Don’t question me. I need to feel better about this and your questions are stopping me doing that.’ Sorry, not buying it. Tell me how you’re genuinely going to help our country ‘pull together’ and I’ll listen. Otherwise please shut up.

And I am doing something. I have joined a political party. I have joined the electoral reform society. I am attending a solidarity rally tomorrow for our city. I have signed petitions, however futile they might seem. I am taking action. I am attempting to get us out of this ****. I am reading everything I can find across every media source I can get to educate myself about what is happening to my country. I’m not cherry picking what I want to see and turning a blind eye to everything else.

What are you doing?

Fourthly, to the people who have actually said: ‘Enough now. I’m bored of this.’ Did you really think it would all be done and dusted by Friday tea time? As I said in my last post, this is the beginning of something that is going to have seismic repercussions for our country for years. Prepare to be bored witless, and frankly, don’t complain to me. I don’t have time to be bored. I’m too busy being horrified and upset.

Fifthly. Please, please don’t repeatedly tell me we are ‘Free’ now. We are not free. We are still in the EU, and with nobody willing to pull the trigger on article fifty, we may well be there for a good deal longer. Even if we had done it on Friday, please tell me how much freer you are, in real terms. If you can’t point to anything, please feel free to shut up. And what are you doing with that precious new freedom? Please enlighten me.

Sixthly: I am watching, over the last few days, in absolute horror as the far right start to move out of the shadows and back into centre stage again. My time line has been pinging with people reporting hate crime. There’s even a Twitter feed for it where they are gathering information in order to report it. It’s appearing in reports on my community Facebook page. It’s in my daughter’s school. It’s like someone took the lid off Pandora’s Box. Don’t tell me I’m exaggerating. Don’t tell me that reports can be twisted. Maybe they can, but it’s being taken seriously enough by everyone that matters and it is tabled for discussion in the House of Commons this week. It’s not as if they haven’t got other things to talk about. It’s happening and I’m appalled but sadly, not surprised.

Apropos of this, please do not tell me: ‘I’m not a racist’ if you voted leave. I get that, but I said that it would open the door to the far right, and it has and to pretend it hasn’t, and to not look or think about it is cowardly. And to say ‘I’m not a racist,’ is to imply that I’m making all this about you. I’m not, but I have a right to get angry and upset about the consequences of a decision you were a part of, however noble your intentions.

Seventhly, to the people who are saying we are now able to govern ourselves and we are free of the unelected shackles of Brussels dictating to us. Farage is unelected. Gove/Boris or whoever takes over from Cameron will be unelected. The House of Lords is unelected. The queen, who keeps being wheeled out as a symbol of our great democracy for reasons I cannot understand, is unelected. You are being taken into the future by largely unelected fuckwits who have already lied to you and broken every promise you gave them power for. Do not talk to me about the shackles of Brussels.

Eighthly gets several paragraphs because it’s such a ***********.

Our government has imploded in on itself. Cameron made one, cowardly speech on Friday and bailed on us. Now most of the conservatives are too busy fighting about who is going to be the inheritor of the steaming turd bequeathed by Cameron to do anything useful for us.

George Osborne, who only came out of hiding this morning and said ‘the economy is strong.’ This is not borne out in the annuities market crashing, RBS and Barclays suspending trading and the pound dropping like a stone, again. So for all those of you who smilingly told me that everything was fine and it was all over by Friday tea time, what say you now?

And I reiterate. This is only the start.

Boris finally emerging yesterday. His statement was not a statement, it was an article he wrote because that’s his job, and he got paid £5,000 to do it. He has admitted that he wants to stay in Europe, however Europe will have him. This means that we go to the single market or EEA. This means, for those of you who don’t know by now, that we pay the same amount into the EU as we have done previously in order to trade with them. It means that we still have to comply with all their trading regulations. It means that we still have to allow freedom of movement across borders. The one thing it doesn’t mean is that we get to keep our veto. So we have gambled everything for less. None of the things the leavers want will happen, but we will also be much worse off in almost every conceivable way. This basically means that what the leave campaigners fought for and won, was Boris’ ambition to run the country, not the ‘freedom’ of the nation.

Daniel Hannan, a major player in the leave campaign who voted to be ‘tough’ on immigration, has now back tracked on his promise and actually left twitter for a month because he’s exhausted from campaigning. How convenient. I already covered the lies about the £350 million, which have become more and more byzantine as the weekend has progressed.

Then there’s the implosion of the Labour party under Corbyn with MPs resigning in droves from his cabinet and a vote of no confidence expected any moment. I have seen both sides of the argument on Twitter and I am ashamed of them all. It smacks of fiddling while Rome burns.

In the meantime, Farage has suggested that the sensible thing to do would be to sack Mark Carney, the head of the Bank of England because he was too partisan before the referendum. Mark Carney, as far as I can see, is the only thing standing between us and having to wheel our pay home at lunch time in a barrow, and spend it before tea time to cheat devaluation. The only reason the markets rallied on Friday was because he’d stashed £250 billion down the sock drawer and waved it around a bit. It wasn’t because the markets had confidence in us, it was because he showed them the money.

And they are playing at this. None of them are making decisions. None of them are doing anything. Our country is a laughing stock, our economy is in free fall and our government has washed its hands of us in favour of stabbing each other in the back.

I’m glad to say there is no ninthly and tenthly, but at the rate we’re going, there will be by tea time.

I just realized, just remembered that I am only half English. My dad died some 16 years ago, so it's an easy thing to forget for me.

He was a Hungarian migrant.

As I see it, this has given me full right to take all rhetoric about immigrants very personally.

Britiain is a nation of migrants.

Only the right wing morons dont get that. Essentially they are all a mix of roman, danish, norman, french, german etc etc

Billy Connolly, one of Scotland's most famous 'white' comedians and as Scottish as Scottish gets has Indian grandparentage!