Thanks for the great series - Today, a friend and I just started our own little OCTGN progression series (just epically failed Journey along the Anduin after drawing two hill trolls right at the beginning and holding off a storm of enemies, just to be, after finally embarking on the raft, finished off by a nasty suite of treacheries - very fun
- we failed to bring any healing effects which turned out to be a bad choice ).
I have been thinking about what to do with scenarios that were released in-between cycles. In particular 1) when to play promotional scenarios, 2) when to add in cards from the Saga expansion, and 3) when to play Saga expansions.
It looks like you are skipping the promotional scenarios for now (As far as I know Massing at Osgiliath was released before the Hills of Emyn Muil). I guess in your old progression series you played that scenario after the entire Shadows of Mirkwood cycle. Reasonable - I can imagine it to be extremely luck dependent with a card pool just up to Rhosgobel (without Boromir etc.). I found it to be a (all be it fun) challenge even with cards up to Khazad Dum...
As for the Saga expansions, it could be a little odd to play the Hobbit 1, then Heirs of Numenor, then the Hobbit 2; or to play the Black Riders in the middle of the Against the Shadows cycle, then wait until the Road darkens was released in the middle of the Ringmaker etc. Especially if one wants to enjoy campaign mode. However, I guess one could expand the card pool at the correct times and continue playing the regular cycles?
In any case, for anyone who has been there, I was just wondering what your solutions and thoughts were on handling this issue .
Happy questing and thanks!
Hey there, Aaron!
Thank you very much for reaching out and expressing your appreciation for the series. I'll be sure to share your post with Matthew, as he and I both always love hearing from viewers ![]()
What I intend to do for this series is to play through everything in "mostly" chronological order. You're quite right that The Massing at Osgiliath came out very early indeed - in fact, it was first available at Gen Con alongside Conflict at the Carrock! That's a lot of scenario for not a large pool of player cards, and for this ongoing Progression Series, Matthew and I intend to play PoD stuff inbetween cycles. One notable exception to this rule was back in the original Progression Series, when Matthew and I played The Battle of Lake-Town between the second and third scenario of The Hobbit: On the Doorstep saga expansion; it just seemed natural (and narrative-appropriate), to do so. On this channel, I intend to "take a break" from the Progression Series when, chronologically, a Saga Expansion was released.
For instance, we will do the following in order:
Shadow and Flame - Progression Series Episode X
The Hobbit: Over Hill and Under Hill - (one evaluation series episode, 3+ saga series episodes)
Heirs of Numenor - (one evaluation series episode, 3+ progression series episodes)
The Hobbit: On the Doorstep - (one evaluation series episode, 3+ saga series episodes)
Steward's Fear - Progression Series Episode Y
As a box or adventure pack is opened, we'll be adding those cards to our card pool moving forward. So, I hope that explains quite clearly what he and I intend to do, but you're certainly welcome to do whatever you'd like. For more detail about the ongoing Progression Series, check out the now slightly outdated project summary.
Here's hoping that you have a bit better luck, moving forward! For what it's worth, I don't think I've ever faced two first-turn Hill Trolls, when playing Journey Along the Anduin
So again, thanks for reaching out, and best wishes to you!
Edited by TheHiveTyrant