Which Rebel list is better?

By horsepire, in X-Wing Squad Lists

Hi all,

Pretty casual player here, but I've come up with a couple of combos that I really like, and I'm thinking about entering a tournament sometime over the summer to try my hand against better competition. The two lists here are very similar but I can't decide which one is better. I haven't flown either and maybe that's what it will come down to, but I wanted outside opinions.

List 1:

-Keyan Farlander with Rage, E/2, Hera Syndulla

-Wedge Antilles with Stay on Target, R2, Integrated Astromech

-Poe Dameron with Adaptability, R5-P9, Autothrusters

List 2:

-Keyan Farlander with Rage

-Wedge Antilles with Stay on Target, Targeting Astromech, Integrated Astromech

-Poe Dameron with Veteran Instincts, R5-P9, Autothrusters

Both 100 points exactly. As you can see, very similar lists. I LOVE Hera on Keyan with Rage in List 1, but to free up the points, I have to lose a point of pilot skill on Poe and TA on Wedge. Wedge hits much harder in List 2, where he can reposition and still acquire a target lock, but losing Hera makes Keyan much more predictable the turn after he triggers rage.

Thoughts?