I say B, with one tiny adjustment.

Modified loss needs to be 0 points. Otherwise, the players can fabricate an ID by figuring out what they need to destroy from each other and then wait for time to both secure at least 1 point.

That's my thinking, too.

But I really like the idea of extra points for tabling someone.

Full Win (lost no ships & destroyed all opponent 's ships): 3 points

Standard Win: 2 points

Modified Win (by less than 12 points): 1 point

Loss: 0 points

I think this would solve the ID problem and also make later rounds more exciting as you could jump up the table with a full win. Although I guess it would work against swarms...

Vs

Option C

I like what Voidstate posted better.

The problem is with MOV itself as it tries to fix a problem but can lead to draws. I have been in one myself and time was called as we were shooting each other so none of the pansy avoiding a fight. But most draws are as people try to save MOV points.

I am considering ramifications of only counting the damage caused to others. With Voidstate points that rewards the dominate games and draws become only valuable if they have played the game. With large ship with more than half damage is half points, I think this system might actually work.