Jan Ors or Jyn Erso? (Did Disney killed Dark Forces?)

By Marinealver, in X-Wing

So looking at the trailer it looks like the same plot from Dark Forces, that classic FPS often called a Doom Clone with Star Wars skin where you steal the Death Star plans and give it to Princess Leia.

So in Dark Forces there was two main characters. Kyle Katan (the player) who was the person that was on foot there was also Jan Ors who acted more as the boss. She recruited Kyle Katan into the alliance and ends up giving him his missions. However in the trailer while it sounded similar only in the vaguest of context it looks like Disney will replace the duo with well a girl.

So I guess the question is this the Dark Forces plot and are these the same characters or has it been scrapped like the rest of the EU?

Disney will replace the duo with well a girl.

star-wars-rogue-one-cast-1200x630.jpg

yup. she's the only one in the movie.

Disney will replace the duo with well a girl.

star-wars-rogue-one-cast-1200x630.jpg

yup. she's the only one in the movie.

So you mean none of the 5 dudes is Kyle Katan or Kile Kaiten?

If you haven't realized kannan is a mix of Dash and Kyle... This already happened with rebels.

It's Jan Ors. I get why people think she said Ursa, but I reckon it's "Ors, Sir".There is a 'look' at a guy in the corner that could well be Kyle.

So excited for this one :)

It's Jan Ors. I get why people think she said Ursa,

It does help that IMDB lists it as Jyn Erso.

Mise well be Jyn Odan.

Dark forces was practically my first FPS I loved, especially with Jedi Knight.

That being said, I think you may be forgetting what most of Dark Forces was about. The first mission was 1 man Katarn stealing the death star plans. No team, no nothing. The entire rest of the game was dedicated to tracking down dark troopers, the super powerful robots with a really cool gun that shot big balls of energy AND had a rocket launcher. For the most part, honestly, Kyle's role in stealing the DS plans is relatively un-important and was just in the game for sales (the demo was the first level after all).

Does that mean that Jan Ors and Katarn are gone? No, it just means that they personally didn't steal the deathstar plans. Unless of course that really is Jan, only time will tell.

For all we know, Katarn and Jan could be the stars of the potential live action show set on Nar Shadda from the remnants of 1313.

It's Jan Ors. I get why people think she said Ursa,

It does help that IMDB lists it as Jyn Erso.

Mise well be Jyn Odan.

Yeah, but that info comes from subtitles, and if they were voice recognition rather than taken from script it could be way wrong. Wait and see :)

Its jan ors.

with a `sir` at the end.

compare it to the way she sais `sir` again at about :57

I hope it's not Ors. That means less new crew and pilot possibilities.

Its jan ors.

with a `sir` at the end.

compare it to the way she sais `sir` again at about :57

sorry.

Cos subtitles are never wrong ;) seriously, wait until the cast list is out. Check out the character bio. This is Ors.

Those aren't subtitles auto-made by youtube. That's the video released by Star Wars FR. They have a dubbed version too, but no subtitles.

Its jan ors.

with a `sir` at the end.

compare it to the way she sais `sir` again at about :57

Even if that were true (and I wish it was), she doesn't say 'Jan', she says 'Jyn'.

And she doesn't say 'Ors' (as in the things needed to row a boat), she says 'Urs'.

Unless she's adopting a South African accent (!), in which case forget all the above...

I love the Dark Forces / Jedi Knight series, infact Kyle and Jan have gone down as my favorite characters in the entire EU/Legends and Dark Forces was the game that inspired me at a young age to work towards getting into the games industry.

That being said, Disney wanted a fresh start for new fans and nixed the EU/Legends which is sad, but not terrible, things can still be retconned or head-canoned in if you wish.

I run a Star Wars RPG game and I usually reconcile the two canons in any way I can if possible. In this instance I simply state that Kyle and Jan did not get their hands on the actual plans, but they were the team that discovered about the weapons test and got the information that will assist the 'Rogue One' team in their mission. They still play a part in getting the plans, but not alone and directly.

Cos subtitles are never wrong ;) seriously, wait until the cast list is out. Check out the character bio. This is Ors.

You sound awful confident for someone who is completely contradicted by literally everything we've seen to date.

IMDb shows the name as Jyn Erso, thank god...

For a second , I thought she was speaking Gungan & almost had a panic attack

(Me-sah name is Jyn Ors-sah and me am bombad rebel spy)

I heard there's another character, not in the trailer, called Luck SkewWokier

Edited by XBear

IMDb shows the name as Jyn Erso, thank god...

For a second , I thought she was speaking Gungan & almost had a panic attack

(Me-sah name is Jyn Ors-sah and me am bombad rebel spy)

I'd walk out of the theater and demand my money back if she spoke like that.

It's cute when people still dream of EU characters showing up.

Disney will replace the duo with well a girl.

star-wars-rogue-one-cast-1200x630.jpg

yup. she's the only one in the movie.

So you mean none of the 5 dudes is Kyle Katan or Kile Kaiten?

Im more interested in seeing Ip Man do kungfu with a lightsaber.

Disney will replace the duo with well a girl.

star-wars-rogue-one-cast-1200x630.jpg

yup. she's the only one in the movie.

So you mean none of the 5 dudes is Kyle Katan or Kile Kaiten?

Im more interested in seeing Ip Man do kungfu with a lightsaber.

Can we please have 1 stand alone film with NO jedi?

Just 1

Just pretend it's Jan and all the stories your know still happened and this is another. Doesn't hurt anyone.

I'd like to pretend Revan, Dash and Xizor is still canon. Makes me happy

Edited by CheapCreep

Jan or not Jan makes no difference. The Legends character most know and love will likely have little in common with this new iteration.

Disney went clean slate with all existing video games as well. Best to treat this like you've been MIB'd. In other words, what you think you know you do not know. Otherwise you're gonna have a bad time.

And if they borrow the plot directly from Dark Forces, with Jan taking a more direct role, what then?

Frankly, they can do that. If they want to take the game and write a direct translation of that to the big screen (or at least expanding the first level and using Kyle's and Jan's backstory to lead up to it more), they have every right to. Changing the names is just fine.

But me, I'll just sit here and watch.