Someone told me that if you Have A and C in the same list, both with the title, and destroy a ship with either of them, both get a shield back.

My interprention was that you only get a shield back with the ship IG that actually does the kill.

So which one is correct?

'you' on a card refers to the ship.

So if C destroys a ship, it gets a shield back, A doesn't. It did not perform the attack after all.

Just as I thought. Thanks