Yes it's out of line to offer negative input on a list without being asked. Same with assuming someone has the capacity to spend more money on the hobby. It's rude and doesn't contribute to a positive play experience, which is really all a TO should be striving towards.There may be some overeacting here. The TO offered some tips to make the list more effective, is this such a bad thing? This is a game that involves spending money, is it out of line for someone to suggest buying certain ships?
Absolutely. The last thing you want to be doing before a tournament starts is second guessing yourself and the list you're using.
I provided a nice cheap suggestion earlier also don't forget ![]()