Kwing bomb dropping question

By Krynn007, in X-Wing Rules Questions

Can marinda move then drop a proton bomb when slamming.

Having a game and can't remember where I read something about that, but don't see it in faq

No.
This was an error in the K-Wing article.

It's still debated, but if a SLAM does count as revealing a maneuver, Navigator becomes absolutely broken (while its still powerful without it working that way).

Edited by DraconPyrothayan

No.

This was an error in the K-Wing article.

It's still debated, but if a SLAM does count as revealing a maneuver, Navigator becomes absolutely broken (while its still powerful without it working that way).

I thought Navigator counted as a 'new' reveal because you're still manipulating the dial. How is SLAM counting as a revealed maneuver going to make Navigator broken?

No.

This was an error in the K-Wing article.

It's still debated, but if a SLAM does count as revealing a maneuver, Navigator becomes absolutely broken (while its still powerful without it working that way).

I thought Navigator counted as a 'new' reveal because you're still manipulating the dial. How is SLAM counting as a revealed maneuver going to make Navigator broken?

Navigator is triggered upon the revelation of the dial.

No-where does it say that manipulation results in a new revelation.

All abilities that manipulate the dial re-affirm the stress-rule that is otherwise rendered redundant if it is a new revelation.

Pretty clear to me its not a new revelation.

OK, I think I wasn't quite clear enough there. I didn't mean it as a fresh new reveal. I meant it as an update to the reveal. You're still only revealing the dial once.

And as far as SLAM was concerned, I thought they put that one to bed a while ago when they established the article was incorrect and a SLAM was an action and not a new dial reveal. It's also clearly not a manipulation of the current dial.

The article was in error and has been corrected. The most recent FAQ also addresses it: SLAM is not revealing a dial so no trigger for dropping bombs.

Ya that's how we played it.

Was in a game when I made this post.

Thanks for the replies

I couldn't find it in the faq, but knew I saw it somewhere

I was pretty sure I had the most updated faq.

What page is It on?