D'Anna Biers version 2.0

By [email protected], in Battlestar Galactica

My first blush opinion is that it's too narrow a character set of abilities. Also, too powerful - or too weak - in that singular way. Looking at all cards going in to a skill check is way too much. Maybe she can look at one player. Either way, she's going to be encouraged to spend a lot of time just being a cylon detector. If she doesn't care who the cylons are, now she has no other real powers. As for getting boxed and taking a new character, that's not a real disadvantage and it's just not "fun," in my eyes.

Edited by Anacreon

So, she would look at the cards going into the check (simlar to Investigative committe but just for her) but she would still be bound by secracy rules?

If so, its interesting, but redundant somewhat to the OPG.

It also has to go off "fast" due to the sleeper phase part.

I think she would have stronger abilites for "winning" as the new style "multiple agenda" cylon leader.

Maybe her once per game coule be SHOWING that cards 1 player put into the check, HAHA.... there is some paranoia for you!

How about if you have not miracle token, you are boxed? Not sure that helps...