Ok, so I know this has likely been asked a gajillion times by now but here goes again.

I have the base game and Dunwich horror. I love both of them.

Now I want to know which one is guna give me the best bang for the buck.

I'm curious about the personal stories aspect, as well as epic battles and heralds / guardians. Anyone have any personal experiences or opinions?

(Also..how in the world do you play with all the boards? I'd have to play it on the floor.)

Scaresoul said:

Weird that you put it like that. I've always played all my games on the floor.

But..the floor is so hard..and floor-like.

Scaresoul said:

Life is hard, better get used to it .

Scaresoul said:

Personally i find that the main benefit of the expansions is to give you the option of having very different games of AH, not simply to add more stuff, and hence I tend to play with only one or two expansions at a time.

I can't really say which expansion is better than others, but here's my plans:

Base

Dunwich

King in Yellow

Kingsport

Curse of Dark Pharaoh

(Innsmouth and Black Goat will be last)

It's a good thing I have a table tennis table, that thing can fit any board game on it.

Knuckles Eki said:

Ah, a challenge. Get a copy of the Longest Day and see if you can fit THAT on your table tennis table. Battalion level simulation of the entire western front, at 3 km per hex. When I set it up for a campaign game, it took up the floor of an entire room of my house with enough room to scoot around the outside to play and have the various order of battle sheets.

http://www.boardgamegeek.com/image/264876