Which list for Store Championship

By Corabb, in X-Wing Squad Lists

Hey all,

I'm new here and rather new to X-Wing.

Can't decide what to take for upcoming Store Championship this coming weekend, please help.

List #1

Soontir, PTL, Autothrusters - 32

OMG, Darth Vader - 24

2x Academy Pilot - 24
Howlrunner, Swarm Tactics - 20

Total 100 points

List #2

Echo, Advanced Cloaking Device, Fire Control System, Veteran Instincts, Intelligence Agent - 38

Dark Curse, Targeting Computer - 18
Vessery, Veteran Instincts, Heavy Laser Cannon - 43

Total 99 points

What do You think about these lists, which is better, what to change?

I'm really want to use Defender, but also know that first list is more forgiving if I make stupid mistakes.

I don'tknow what to choose.

In my imperial mind there is also a rebel idea of :)

Luke, R2D2, Lone Wolf - 34

2x Blue Sq B-Wing - 44

Green Sq A-Wing - PTL, Autothrusters, Chardaan Refit - 22

Thanks!

List #1 has an answer for everything.

List #2 seems very fragile.

We do not fly Rebel Scum, so no comments on List #3 ;)

Edited by Keffisch

I love Tie Defenders too so Im biased to list 2

Id suggest swapping out Dark Curse for Backstabber. Far bigger threat. Most people would just ignore DC until last.

It's also not a very noob-friendly list, you need to know your templates really well to get the most out of a phantom.

I love Tie Defenders too so Im biased to list 2

Id suggest swapping out Dark Curse for Backstabber. Far bigger threat. Most people would just ignore DC until last.

It's also not a very noob-friendly list, you need to know your templates really well to get the most out of a phantom.

I was thinking that Dark Curse would be perfect for target locking all day for Vessery, Backstabber life will be rather short.

About Echo I'm worried too, but don't know what to take instead.