Though you see in the original movies that they have this pattern, with dialogue enlivening the dead zones in the fight.
Well, Return of the Jedi and Empire Strikes Back do it pretty well. Obi-Wan and Vader on the Death Star, though, look like a pair of arthritic old men... which is appropriate for at least one of them, of course, but isn't exactly inspiring.
Yeah, this is true. But I think part of the issue with that is the fight is heavily dependent on kendo techniques, and is rooted in Akira Kurosawa's films (of which Lucas was a huge fan). So, the scene mimics a lot of samurai movies with little movement and a lot of facing off. I think, though, it came off as looking the way you describe, which is why the fights are markedly more physical in ESB and RotJ.
Agreed. However, Kurosawa (and Sergio Leone, for that matter) made those calm spots before & in the middle of combat just amazing. The tension of warriors just staring, trying to read the opponent... I think it's as good as the fight itself.
Now imagine a scene like that, with all that weight, instead of The Amazing Bouncing Yoda.
