I'm a bit confused.
Suppose: I roll 3 damage and 1 surge against my opponent, he rolls 1 defense.
My skill says: pay 1 surge: either +1 damage or gain 1 pierce.
Pierce means: negate 1 defense
so....
if I up my damage I do 4 damage -1 defense; totals 3
If I pierce I keep 3 damage and ignore his defense through pierce I get: total 3
Seems to me this choice is between an apple and an apple, where is the difference?
I made up a houserule for this that changes Pierce into : reroll 1 yellow die. This means, I could get also - 1 damage- but also a chance on 2 or if it fails a 0. Guess his armor was tougher..
Am I missing something in the rules?