Dual BH+doom shuttle vs dual BH+2 academies

By Jaden Ckast, in X-Wing Squad Lists

So just curious what opinions about these 2 lists there are. First I love firesprays and do very well with them and my lost usually looks like this.

1 BH w/gunner

1 BH w/rebel captive

1 basic doom shuttle

While I have still won a majority of my engagements with this list I still find my doom shuttle to be the weak link. Usually it sees 2 maybe 3 turns of firing before it's making the long turn around. I try to stall with as long as possible and rush with my BH's to strip shields then come in with vader. However I just don't like having nothing to shoot at for 2 or more turns whilei try to turn around and get into position again. So I was thinking of this list instead.

1 BH w/rebel captive+anti pursuit lasers

1 BH w/gunner

2 academy pilots

Basically rush with the rebel captive BH and try and block so they are forced to overlap and shoot at it while my gunner BH hangs about 2 ranges behind. My ties try to flank.

So basically 4 less hp with this list but more mobility and more rounds of shooting with them.

Any thoughts about which you would take to a store championship?

if the doom shuttle is flown good, it can pop 1 academy right away. i for myself cant fly the shuttle, but i seen it used greatly and they arent called DOOMshuttle for nothing