Sure they can ruin any ship pretty fast if the crits get through. That is a pretty big IF ! You can search the treads for all the post about how the dice screwed them in a game and this can go both ways. Sure the dice can go with you and could get an overwelming victory. you can accept the average and lose or have the dice against you and never hit the ships ever. In my opinion you are leaving the game to the dice if you rely on Mangler Cannon on getting you the victory on Autothrusters.
The case will be made by how the meta works out. The risk to Autothrusters is a reduction in the turreted ships being flown. If the number drops enough where these points become wasted the Mangler Cannon will out perform the HLC. SO it really boils down to where the meta stands. For all we know there could be a build in the Scum that tosses this all out the windown and leaves both the turreted ships and Autothrusters outside looking in.
Edited by Osoroshii