I've been thinking a lot about the concept of Traits , and the line they straddle between mechanical importance and thematic importance. Sometimes they appear inconsistently, and this situation toys mercilessly with my OCD. For example, in the Star Wars LCG we have the Emperor's Royal Guard, which appropriately has the Imperial Guard trait; whereas the Imperial Shadow Guard does not, despite representing a secret cadre pulled from the already-elite ranks of the Royal Guard. I give this one a pass, though, because I believe it's an issue of space on the card, and nobody likes reducing font size as it just looks wrong. But it's still inconsistent. Ideally, cards should be both consistent and tidy, and the irony is that sometimes one of these must come at the expense of the other.
But in the case of A Game of Thrones: The Card Game , the most important traits that may appear in Second Edition, I feel, are house traits; e.g. House Frey . But more and more I am finding myself of the opinion, again as an OCD fan and as someone deeply invested in the lore of the setting, that these should not be traits at all, but should instead be built into the card's title, both to save space and to leave open the possibility of future cards that refer to them. Rather than giving Walder Frey the " House Frey " trait and having cards that look for said trait, why not simply have them look for the "Frey" in his name? All that would be needed for this to work would be the elimination of epithetical names for characters; e.g. "The Hound" and "Littlefinger" versus "Sandor Clegane" and "Petyr Baelish," which again feels inconsistent to me, since in the books these characters are referred to by their actual names often enough that they could serve. This idea might be slightly harder to accomplish with Army cards: "King Robb's Legion" would not work whereas "Robb Stark's Legion" would, but with some dedication I feel it could be achieved (and to be fair, in this case the card should probably have no house synergy at all, since it likely represents a collection of various banner houses pledged to Robb Stark). It would also pose an issue for Ramsay Snow/Bolton, but one could argue that this is a case in which there could be two versions of the character with separate names to represent him before and after his legitimization, with text that clarifies them to represent the same person.
What do you guys think about this idea? Good? Bad? Discuss.