OT: That's no moon....

By DraconPyrothayan, in X-Wing

http://xkcd.com/1458/

small_moon.png

"GENERAL JAN DODONNA: An analysis of the plans provided by Princess Leia has reinvigorated the arguments of the 'Artificial Moonlet' and the 'Rogue Planet-Station' camps. I fear this question is fracturing the Rebellion."

It can't be a moon. It's not orbiting anything.

It can't be a moon. It's not orbiting anything.

I think an assumption that could have been made at that point of the movie is that it WAS orbiting Alderaan.

"It's heading for that small rogue planetoid formerly known as a moon."

Rogue planets don't orbit a Sun anymore, but they are still planets.