Are these squads worthy

By Jbird793, in X-Wing

I came up with two different squads not sure if they're good enough or if one is better then the other

First squad

"Whisper" +VI + ACD = 37 pts

Sigma squadron pilot + Stygium = 27pts

Scimitar squadron pilot + seismic x2 = 36

Second squad

"Whisper" + VI + ACD = 37pts

Sigma squadron pilot + Stygium = 27

Bounty hunter + proximity mine = 36

I think you have a pretty standard loadout for whisper. I am personally not sold on the unnamed phantoms. I have had limited success with bombers and bombs. They are pretty weak offensively and the bombs are hard to predict when is best to use them. For the bounty hunter, I have had a lot of success running a BH with recon spec.

Pretty much what darthjeff said.

That second squad is a good start.

Swap the proxy mine for recon spec

Id also swap out the sigma for a pair of ties

The only valid test is combat -- usually versus multiple lists. The only valid result is victory :).