The biggest shortcoming of A-Wings is the lousy unique pilot options. The 19 cost Green with a useful EPT is great. Tycho is expensive, but his power can be very useful- just not often what you want to center your team on. But otherwise they desperately need the new Aces uniques.
A better A-Wing
All that means to me is that the current trends in competitive strategy do not favor the A-Wing's specialties. A TIE Swarm cannot be outflanked. Neither can a Falcon. Wave 4 probably changes that, as Tycho is an excellent Phantom hunter.
There have been 4 wave 4 Regionals, total attendance of 126 players. There have been exactly zero A-wings in the Final Cut or Top Third. Feel free to revisit these statistics later until Rebel Aces is legal....
While I believe that Tycho is an excellent Phantom hunter, I am under no delusion that he is the only option for that. Furthermore, as Falcons and TIE swarms are still very much a part of the dominant tournament meta-game, I wouldn't expect anyone to take a chance on an A-Wing for fear of facing these counters.
Guys, I watched Tycho chew through my e-wing and a b-wing as we charged up the middle of the asteroids, head on.
A-wings are no joke.