Baelor Blacktyde

By HastAttack, in 2. AGoT Rules Discussion

Posted at

" Opponents cannot play copies of event cards that are in their discard piles "

My opponents prevented me from bringing Fiery Kiss out of shadows ~ as I had a copy in my discard pile

I don't think that is correct .... Do I "play" a card when I bring it out of shadows?

Posted at

In the rules for the shadows mechanics says:

"After an event card comes out of Shadows, it is treated in the same manner as a non-Shadows event card played from a player’s hand"
then I think that is correct for Baelor to prevent you from play the Fiery Kiss from shadows, when you have one or more in the discard pile.
Posted at

Incorrect. The "as if you played it from your hand" doesn't kick in until after the card comes out of Shadows. Bringing a card out of Shadows is not playing it. So Baelor cannot stop you from bringing an event card out of Shadows.

Posted at

Thanks Ktom ... it's a shame you cannot sit in on our games :)

Posted at

We all need a Ktom in our games! :)

Posted at

Ok

I did misunderstood this part, sorry for my bad answer :unsure: , and thanks Ktom for your answers.