Biggs/Tarn question that came up last night

By Rhinoviru3, in X-Wing Rules Questions

I've tried searching for an answer to this one (it may be such a simple answer that nobody thought to post the question before) but this was a scenario that happened at my LGS yesterday on the table next to me:

Player 1 has Biggs, Tarn, and some other ships.

Player 2 has a swarm of TIE's.

Player 2, with Howlrunner, (forgetting Biggs was a thing) declared Tarn to be the target of attack. Player 1 rightly said that Biggs had to be target of the attack as per Biggs pilot ability. Player 1 reads the card, acknowledges his mistake, but points out that he still could declare Tarn as the target and thus trigger his pilot ability.

It was a friendly, and I believe they ruled it that Tarn got his free lock (they were giddy to try him out, lol!)

Was this correct? Can Tarn be declared as a target, only to have it switched to Biggs (like the sponge that he is), or must Biggs be the only declare-able target?

Biggs-darklighter.png

Biggs pilot ability blocks choosing another ship as a target before you targeting Biggs. You could not target Tarn and then switch to Biggs as Tarn is not a legal target to choose with Biggs in play.

This is what came up; they cannot be targeted but can they be declared?

I may be reading too much into it, but I was curious as to the outcome as I may run a similar list soon...

My take on " cannot be targeted by attacks" is to mean that you can't even declare tham as a target or even try to start the declare/targeting process.

It all has to be on Biggs.

Excellent. Nice to hear it from other forum-ers!

Page 10:

During this step, the attacker (the active ship) must declare its target (the ship he wishes to attack). The target ship must be inside the attacker’s firing arc and within range.
It's a little fuzzy on the exact timing and terminology, but based on the range/arc restrictions I think you cannot "declare" an illegal target. So no picking Tarn if Biggs was there.