opinions on my lists plz

By eibon, in X-Wing

ok so im a pretty new player n wanted ur guyz opinions on my two listsplz dont b too harsh im new remember haha.

1. kath+marksmanship+gunner+seismic charge

4x obsidian pilots

2. kir kanos+stealth device

RG pilot+stealth device+targeting computer

scimitar squadron pilot+cluster missles (fletchete torps+munitions failsafe when released)

2x acadamy pilot.

thanks.

I would go with option 1, because 22 HP will help you last a little bit longer than 18 will.

But drop the seismic charges, drop down to Academy Pilots, and swap one out with Howlrunner. Then you've got yourself a nice little mini-swarm with a heavy hitter to mop up while you are recovering from K-turns.

Nothing awful about list 1. I wonder why Obsidian instead of Academy, but it works.

On list 2, ditch the clutsters, ditch the targeting computer, pick up a Bomb and an EPT instead.

I would go with option 1, because 22 HP will help you last a little bit longer than 18 will.

But drop the seismic charges, drop down to Academy Pilots, and swap one out with Howlrunner. Then you've got yourself a nice little mini-swarm with a heavy hitter to mop up while you are recovering from K-turns.

I don't actually know if Howlrunner's bonus is better than the Seismic Charges.

I'd be particularly intrigued by Proton Bombs and Initiative instead of Seismics and a PS bid.

As controversial as it may b im not a fan of howl, I no she works really well but I prefer diff list to swarm/varient. AP n protons is interesting, I thort bout ditching clusters n munitions for a second fletchete, n targeting comp for PTL