4 ship imperial build or 3 ship rebel?

By Klutz, in X-Wing

I have two squads I'd appreciate comments on, a 4 ship imperial squad and a 3 ship rebel squad.

4 ship empire squad (100 points)

Saber Squadron Pilot (24)

TIE Interceptor (21), Push the Limit (3)

Saber Squadron Pilot (24)

TIE Interceptor (21), Push the Limit (3)

Darth Vader (31)

TIE Advanced (29), Squad Leader / Swarm Tactics (2)

Tempest Squadron Pilot (21)

I've been flying 2xSaber+PTL with Dark Curse + 3xAP, but I find the TIE Fighters die too quickly, without ever dealing any damage. So, I swapped out the 4 APs for Vader + Tempest.

I find it a pity that Vader and TIE Advanceds don't see much use.

3 ship rebel squad (100 points)

Biggs Darklighter (29)
X-Wing (25), Shield Upgrade (4)
Jan Ors (31)
HWK-290 (25), Ion Cannon Turret (5), Nien Nunb (1)
Wedge Antilles (40)
X-Wing (29), R2-D2 (4), Push the Limit (3), Engine Upgrade (4)
Pretty simple list, Jan Ors takes stress to let Wedge fire with 4 attack vs 0 agility on B-Wings, Nien Nunb helps Jan Ors clear his stress and Biggs soaks up some fire so the duo can survive longer.
I know this probably wouldn't survive long but it looks fun ;)