There is an interesting discussion going on at RPG.net: http://forum.rpg.net/showthread.php?720054-Best-edition-of-Warhammer-Fantasy-Roleplay&p=17723664#post17723664

Neat. I'll bust out my flame-resistant environment suit and take a peek.

I find such debates of little value. The internet is a great way to share constructively, it's a bad way to debate civilly.

I could only make it a few pages in. Same song and dance. At this point I don't think the web has much more to offer me as far as WFRP goes. It's not even interesting at this point aside from some 1e guys who actually know their fluff really well.

Yeah, I'll agree with the other posters in this thread. Discussions like these tend to just attract a bunch of elitist rpg-nerds who just want everything to stay the same. It usually turns out many of them have not even tried the edition they are criticizing. I usually check out at the point where someone compares WFRP3 to a board game.