Me and a friend threw down last Friday, and I had a moment I had to ask about - his fighter was almost exactly the distance of the "Are you in range" stick away. The only thing making contact between the two ships was the little nub of plastic where you put the maneuver template between. An 8th of an inch further away and the stick would have passed clean.
Would you have considered that in range to fire at each other?
(For the record, I gave it to him anwyay. We just laughed at the circumstances)